Welded Steel Pipe VS. Seamless Steel Pipe

Welded and Seamless Pipe Differences:

The core difference between seamless steel pipes and welded steel pipes lies in their manufacturing processes, which directly determine their microstructure, mechanical properties, and application areas.

Essential Differences in Manufacturing Processes:

Seamless steel pipes: Made from solid round steel billets, heated and then plastically deformed through processes such as piercing, rolling (hot rolling/cold rolling), drawing, or extrusion, ultimately forming a hollow cross-section without any weld seams.

Welded steel pipes: Made from steel plates or strips (plates), cold-bent or formed into round, square, or other shapes, and then welded together using methods such as high-frequency resistance welding or submerged arc welding, resulting in a continuous weld seam on the pipe body. Based on the weld seam shape, they can be divided into straight-seam welded pipes and spiral welded pipes.

Differences in Microstructure and Properties:

Seamless steel pipes: Because they are manufactured through integral hot deformation, their metal flow lines are complete, and the microstructure is uniform and isotropic throughout the entire cross-section. Therefore, it has inherent advantages in pressure resistance, fatigue resistance, and corrosion uniformity, making it particularly safe and reliable under harsh conditions such as high pressure, high temperature, low temperature, and corrosion.

Welded steel pipes: Their performance is highly dependent on the quality of the base material, welding process, and subsequent treatment. The weld area contains a heat-affected zone, whose microstructure and properties differ from the base material, representing a potential weak point in the pipe body. Therefore, the key to quality control of welded pipes lies in ensuring the integrity and mechanical properties of the weld. Modern advanced welding and heat treatment technologies can produce high-performance welded pipes suitable for high-pressure applications.

Economics and Application Selection:

Seamless steel pipes: Complex production process, higher cost, and size specifications (especially large diameter) are limited by the billet and processing equipment. Mainly used in fields with extremely high safety and reliability requirements, such as: high-pressure boiler tubes, hydraulic system cylinder tubes, petrochemical hydrogenation unit pipelines, aerospace and military pipes.

Welded steel pipes: High production efficiency, low cost, and can produce ultra-large diameter pipes. Widely used in applications requiring high economic efficiency and moderate pressure, such as municipal water and gas transmission pipelines, building structural pipes, low-pressure fluid transportation, and large bridge pile pipes. Among them, straight seam/spiral welded pipes using submerged arc welding technology have also been widely used in onshore and offshore long-distance oil and gas pipelines.

How to Distinguish between Seamless Steel Pipes and Welded Steel Pipes? How to Choose between them in Engineering Applications?

In engineering practice, the selection of seamless steel pipes versus welded steel pipes is a crucial decision involving safety, performance, and economy. The most fundamental difference between the two lies in their manufacturing processes, which leads to a series of performance and cost differences. During engineering construction, the appropriate steel pipe should be selected based on the specific construction conditions, with cost being the primary consideration.

Core identification methods:

1) Manufacturing process (essential difference)

Seamless steel pipes are mainly made from solid steel billets or ingots as raw materials, formed through piercing and winding, and then manufactured through solid plastic deformation processes such as hot rolling, cold rolling, cold drawing, or extrusion. The pipe body has no weld seams. Because seamless steel pipes contain internal cross-sections, this hollow cross-section can be used as a pipeline for transporting fluids.

Welded steel pipes are generally made by processing steel strips or plates into circles or squares under external force, and then welding the surface joints to form a welded steel pipe. A continuous weld seam exists on the pipe body. Common welding processes include electric arc welding, high-frequency welding or low-frequency welding, and cold rolling. All these processes produce welded steel pipes.

Currently, based on the weld shape, steel pipes can be divided into straight seam steel pipes and spiral seam steel pipes, but the welding processes used differ. Spiral seam steel pipes are welded using submerged arc welding, which has the advantages of high welding efficiency and low dust. High-frequency or low-frequency welding is mainly based on the principle of electromagnetic induction, utilizing the alternating charge in a conductor to generate a turbine heating effect in the adjacent area, melting the steel weld and ultimately completing the weld.

2) Appearance and Physical Identification

In terms of appearance, the difference between seamless steel pipes and welded steel pipes lies in the fact that welded steel pipes usually have visible weld reinforcement (inner weld bead) on the inner wall, which feels raised to the touch; while seamless steel pipes have a smooth and continuous inner wall without weld marks.

Weld Inspection: For welded pipes with ground outer surfaces, non-destructive testing methods such as eddy current testing or magnetic particle testing can be used to reveal the weld.

Wall thickness uniformity: High-quality welded steel pipes (such as those produced using the UOE process) can achieve very high wall thickness control precision; however, seamless steel pipes, especially hot-rolled pipes, have relatively poor wall thickness uniformity, and deviations may occur within the same cross-section.

Core considerations for engineering applications:

1) Size and availability
Seamless steel pipes are limited by the availability of raw materials, making the production of ultra-large diameter (e.g., >Φ660mm) pipes difficult and extremely expensive. Welded steel pipes, on the other hand, offer advantages such as efficient production of ultra-large diameter and extra-thick wall pipes, flexible specifications, and short delivery cycles.

Furthermore, seamless steel pipes have lower dimensional accuracy, relatively thicker walls, and generally lower quality due to the presence of oxide scale on the surface. Welded steel pipes, however, offer very high controllable precision, typically have thinner, more uniform walls, and better surface quality.

2) Working Pressure
Seamless steel pipes have higher pressure resistance and are commonly used in environments with ultra-high pressure, pulsating pressure, and fatigue loads (such as hydraulic systems and compressor pipelines). Welded steel pipes, due to the presence of welds, have lower pressure resistance, generally around 15MPa-20MPa, making them more suitable for medium and low-pressure stable systems (such as municipal water networks and ventilation ducts).

3) Economy and Cost-Effectiveness
Generally, seamless steel pipes are more expensive than welded steel pipes of the same specifications because their production process is more complex and costly. Although the initial material cost of seamless steel pipes is higher, their high reliability and low maintenance costs throughout their entire life cycle may make them more economical.

Of course, for projects with low requirements and budgets, welded steel pipes are the preferred choice for most large-scale, standardized projects due to their lower initial material and manufacturing costs.

4) Performance Characteristics – Media and Environment
Seamless steel pipes: Due to the absence of welded joints, seamless steel pipes typically perform better under extreme conditions, such as high/low temperatures, high pressure, extremely hazardous media (toxic, flammable, explosive), and highly corrosive environments. They are suitable for applications requiring high strength and corrosion resistance, such as oil and gas transportation, the chemical industry, and high-pressure boilers.

Welded Steel Pipes: The performance of welded steel pipes generally depends on the quality of the weld. While welded steel pipes can be used in a variety of applications, the weld can be a potential source of corrosion and insufficient strength. However, these risks can be mitigated through appropriate welding techniques and corrosion protection measures. Seamless steel pipes are superior to welded steel pipes in terms of corrosion resistance, pressure resistance, and high-temperature resistance. Welded steel pipes are more suitable for medium- and low-pressure stable common fluids (water, air, low-pressure steam) and mildly corrosive environments.

5) Applicable Fields – Safety and Regulatory Requirements
Seamless Steel Pipes: Due to their high-performance characteristics, seamless steel pipes are often used in critical equipment fields with high reliability and safety requirements, mandatory regulatory requirements (such as boiler pressure components), and serious consequences of failure, such as nuclear power plants, high-temperature and high-pressure vessels, and chemical equipment.

Welded Steel Pipes: Welded steel pipes are suitable for some general engineering and low-pressure applications, such as conventional building structural support and general fluid transportation, where regulations permit the use of welded pipes. They are generally more affordable.

Seamless steel pipes and welded steel pipes each have their advantages in different application areas. When selecting pipe materials, it is necessary to comprehensively consider project requirements, performance requirements, and cost factors to determine which type of steel pipe is most suitable for a specific project.

Read more: Schedule 80 Carbon Steel Pipe or Carbon Steel vs Black Steel