Carbon steel tube vs Stainless steel tube: material difference and application field analysis

In daily life, carbon steel tube (cs tube) and stainless steel tube(ss tube) are one of the most commonly used piping products. Although they are both used to transport gases and liquids, their materials vary widely. This article will conduct a detailed analysis of the material differences and application fields of carbon steel tubes and stainless steel tubes from four aspects.

Carbon steel tube vs Stainless steel tube:

1. Chemical composition
The main components of carbon steel tube are carbon and iron, containing 1.5% carbon. The main components of stainless steel tubes are iron, chromium, nickel and a small amount of carbon. Therefore, stainless steel tubes not only have the mechanical properties of ordinary steel, but also have good corrosion resistance.

Due to the difference in their chemical composition, carbon steel tubes have higher strength and hardness, while stainless steel tubes have better corrosion resistance. Therefore, their performance differences are obvious in their respective field-specific applications.

2. Cost and maintainability
Stainless steel tubes are more expensive than carbon steel tubes. From a cost and maintainability point of view, carbon steel pipes have a cost advantage over stainless steel tubes because their raw materials and manufacturing costs are lower than stainless steel tubes. In addition, carbon steel tubes are also easier to maintain and replace due to lower repair costs and ease of machining.

Stainless steel tube is more difficult to machine and repair, so it is more expensive to manufacture and repair than carbon steel tube. In addition, the differences between different types of stainless steel tubes are also large, and the selection and installation of stainless steel tubes need to be considered more carefully.

3. Mechanical properties
In terms of mechanical properties, there are also certain differences between carbon steel tubes and stainless steel tubes. Carbon steel tubes have higher strength and hardness, so they are better suited than stainless steel tubes for applications in high pressure and high temperature environments. Stainless steel tubes are weaker in terms of strength and hardness, but are more ductile and corrosion-resistant than carbon steel tubes.

In addition, stainless steel tubes are more ductile than carbon steel tubes in terms of mechanical deformation such as bending and twisting, so they are used more in the aviation and aerospace fields and in the chemical industry due to their better corrosion resistance in extreme environments.

4. Application field

Carbon steel tubes are usually used in the following scenarios:

Conveying high temperature and high pressure fluids
As a load-bearing member of a building
As the skeleton of steel structures and cars
Ventilation ducts for buildings and ducts for air handling systems

Stainless steel tubes are usually more widely used in the following scenarios:

Chemical Industry
Pharmaceutical Industry
marine industry
food processing industry

This is because stainless steel tubes have better corrosion resistance and toughness, and can withstand harsher environments.

Carbon steel vs Stainless steel:

1. Different appearance
Stainless steel is composed of chromium, nickel and other metals, so the appearance of stainless steel is bright silver, smooth in appearance, and has very good gloss. The composition of carbon steel is an alloy of carbon and iron, so the color of carbon steel is gray and the surface is rougher than stainless steel.

2. Different corrosion resistance
Both carbon steel and stainless steel contain iron. Everyone knows that iron elements will slowly oxidize when exposed to the environment, leading to surface rust. However, stainless steel has added chromium. Chromium combines with oxygen better than iron, forming a chromium oxide layer, which can directly protect the steel from degradation and corrosion. The chromium content of carbon steel will also be lower, so the small amount of chromium cannot form a chromium oxide layer, so the corrosion resistance of stainless steel will be better than that of carbon steel.

3. Different wear resistance
Carbon steel is harder than stainless steel, but its weight will be greater and its plasticity
Also lower. Therefore, in terms of wear resistance, carbon steel is more wear-resistant than stainless steel.

4. Different prices
In the process of making stainless steel, a certain amount of other alloys must be added, but carbon steel is completely different from adding a large amount of other alloys, so the price of stainless steel is far more expensive than carbon steel.

5. Different ductility
Generally speaking, steels with higher carbon content are hard and brittle, while steels with lower carbon content are ductile and tough. The ductility of stainless steel will be better than that of carbon steel, mainly because the nickel content in stainless steel is relatively high, and the ductility of these elements is also better, so the ductility of stainless steel will also be better. Carbon steel contains high carbon content, low nickel content, which can be ignored, and poor ductility.

Conclusion:

To sum up, there are certain differences between carbon steel tubes and stainless steel tubes in terms of material, cost, mechanical properties and application fields. Therefore, we should choose the most suitable pipeline product according to the specific application scenario. Of course, when choosing pipeline products, we should not only consider our own needs, but also pay attention to factors such as corrosion and pressure that pipeline products may face, so as to ensure the safety and long-term use of pipelines.

Go here to learn more about" Carbon Steel Pipe Sizes"